What Is Child Labor?
Published November 07, 2009 @ 09:00AM PT
When I was 16, I got my first official job as a hostess at an Applebees is the suburbs of Atlanta, GA. It wasn't the most emotionally fulfilling job I've ever worked, but I made $6.50 a hour (slightly above minimum wage at the time) and my co-workers were nice to me. Before that, at the tender age of 14, I babysat for a family who lived in my neighborhood a few nights a month. At 14 or 16, was I a child laborer? No. My teenage jobs could technically be considered "child labor", but that's not what the term has come to mean.
The term "child labor" is most often used to refer to regular, sustained labor by minors and has a connotation of exploitative or unethical conditions. For example, children who must work to support their families, who are prevented from attending school due to working, who work in dangerous or degrading jobs, or who can't control their working conditions are often considered child laborers. Sometimes, questions of child labor are clear. I was clearly not a child laborer at Applebees because I still went to school, I was free to leave, and my work wasn't dangerous or demeaning (unless you count the time I spilled hot chili con carne on a rather large biker). For children in slavery, in prostitution, or who work long hours instead of going to school, child labor is an appropriate term. The technical meaning could include my job, but when the term "child labor" is used it generally refers to children who work under some type of exploitattive conditions. It's important to understand that when we talk about child labor, we're talking about exploitation and abuse.
Not all cases of child labor are so cut and dry, however. Now, I'm about as sick of hearing about Jon and Kate Gosselin as Mark Sanford is of getting Appalachian Trail souvenirs sent to him, but the recent investigation into whether the Gosselin family or TLC violated child labor laws for Jon and Kate Plus 8 brings up some interesting questions. What do we mean by "work?" If part of the job is going to play at a water park or taking a trip to a science museum, is that work for kids? What do we mean by "length of workday?" What if the cameras film the kids doing things like homework, cleaning their rooms, and brushing their teeth -- things they'd be doing regardless -- but all day long? Do our definitions change if the presence of the television cameras makes them do it in a certain way? And if there was a child labor law violation, whose fault is it? The parents'? TLC's? Ours for watching the show? It's makes us think about child labor in a new light.
But the vast majority of children in child labor are not Applebees hostesses or reality TV stars. According to UNICEF, they are mostly from poor families in rural parts of developing countries. About 158 million children around the world are engaged in child labor. In Sub-Saharan Africa around one in three children are engaged in child labour, and in South Asia, another 44 million are also. Some common industries for child labor include agriculture, factory work, commercial sex, construction materials, and domestic servitude. Child labor robs children of a childhood, and in many cases, an education, healthy physical development, normal psychological development, and freedom.
So keep in mind that when we talk about "child labor," we're not referring to teens working after-school jobs to buy a car or save for college. And we're not even talking about child actors and celebrities most of the time. We're talking about children working long hours for little pay, often at dangerous jobs and with no other options. Child labor is not about building a work ethic or developing skills for children, it's about abuse and exploitation for profit. And it's up to use as consumers not to support users of child labor by not buying their products.
You can see the U.S. Department of Labor's full list of consumer goods made by child labor here. Check it out and know where what you buy comes from.
Photo credit: Afghan Lord
Share this Post
Related Posts
-
2010 Sweatshop Hall of Shame
-
Business Groups Oppose Ban on Child and Slave-Made Products
-
Kraft Foods Commits to Buy More Sustainable Cocoa
Comments (6)
Comments on Change.org are meant for further exploration and evaluation of the ideas covered in the posts. To that end, we welcome constructive comments. However, we reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive, abusive, or off-topic; that contain ad hominem attacks; or that are designed to subvert or hijack comment threads rather than contribute to them. Repeat offenders may be permanently removed from the site at our discretion.
Facebook
Twitter
Digg
StumbleUpon
Delicious
Email



















In Paterson Public Schools (NJ) the students (mostly Spanish) are taken out of their classes ( During Instructional Time) to carry boxes, news papers, heavy teacher's equipment, etc. from floor to floor. When I complained about it to the Administrators (Principals and Vice-Principals), they said to me: "Don't try to do a Police work, just do your job-teaching Spanish." Adding: "Why don't you try to get along with the staff?" Is that right?
So, amigos, Child Labor is not only done on the streets; but inside the schools as well, and what is worse, without pay and sadly, loosing important instructional time.
Carlos A. Garcia
Former Math and Spanish Teacher in Paterson, NJ
Posted by Carlos Alfredo Garcia on 11/07/2009 @ 09:49AM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
It is unusual and definitely not in the children's best interest for them to be taken out of class to transfer materials. However, let's not equate them to the restaveks of Haiti, for instance, who are forced to work 18 hour days with no pay under threat of violence. It's a totally different situation.
Posted by Dennis G. on 11/07/2009 @ 10:32AM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
This topic can definitely bring up a lot of debates. I agree with this article 100%. I think "Child labor" is seen t, especially in little to low income areas. A lot of families tend to focus on their children to help out with Mortgage, groceries, as well as other bills. I believe its alright for an 18 year old or older to have to put towards things in the house such as paying a car payment and insurance, or paying a little for rent. Although i believe that if that 18 year old or older adult is working a job AND going to school its understandable for them not to be able to help out with this. But for the young children, such as 16 year old working two or three jobs, its unbelievable the statistics from 2009 to five or six years ago with the rate of high school drop outs. Speaking from someone who grew up in Baltimore City, it has turned out to be one of the most scary places, honestly. The crime rates and gang violence has risen immensely. Its all related to those young kids having such an expected high amount of responsibility it is overwhelming to them and have no other way out. At their age, to them receiving a paycheck every week is extremely more exciting then having two papers due in a week. At the same time, that's when enough is enough and they can't handle the stress and whats expected from them so they tend to eliminate their duties during the week. Which so happens to be school for most kids.
Posted by Olivia Riley on 11/08/2009 @ 07:44AM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
What you describe here is more an indictment of our current economy rather than an example of child slave labor. While it is unfortunate that a 16 year old would drop out of school and work multiple jobs, the fact that they get a paycheck would, in itself, prove that they are not victims of slave labor. Plenty of kids as young as 16 have jobs, at least part time. Like I said, it is unfortunate that teens have to support themselves and their families by working low wage jobs, but if they are faced with that situation, I applaud their effort in joining the work force as opposed to dealing drugs for instance.
Posted by Dennis G. on 11/08/2009 @ 09:07AM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
People who use contemporary American frames of reference to discuss child labor are not getting close to where the real abuses are occurring, as you point out, Amanda. A century ago, this country did however have serious child labor issues. Some progressive laws helped end, or at least vastly curtail, that problem. As for the Gosselins, I understand you need blog fodder, but is there no place on the Net that is a Gosselin-free zone? ;)
Posted by Slim Chance on 11/08/2009 @ 09:21AM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
I could not agree with you more about the Gosselin reference. While there may be some "labor" questions regarding the children, this example is so far removed from the brutality and severe exploitation suffered by children who are true victims of child/slave labor.
We do a terrible disservice to children around the world who are victims of slave labor, by comparing their plight to that of the Gosselin kids. Indeed, there is no comparison.
Posted by Stephanie Hamilton on 11/11/2009 @ 07:22AM PT
You must be signed in to report content.